I ordered these boots from Amazon and they came yesterday. I desperately need new brown boots, or even ANY other boots besides the rain boots I always wear. However, I have a number of issues with them! First of all, they’re slip-on, and I was rather hoping for zip-up ones, because they’re easier to put on/take off, plus they air out between wearings a LOT better (trust me, this is necessary). But they are also unattractively baggy, which is my main issue with them. They are stiff up to a certain point on the ankle, which provides a nice place for the rest of the boot to rest, making them look pretty ridiculous (in my opinion). It’s worse in not-skinny jeans, which is fine, except that I want to be able to wear any kind of pants with my boots if I need to. But I am open to input. Am I being paranoid and crazy, or do these boots actually look silly?
Top view (this is what I see) in skinny and boot-cut jeans:

Side view (I practically had to contort myself in order to get this angle, which is why my legs look a little weirdly bent in the boot-cut one) in boot-cut and skinny jeans:

And a view of the ankle in different positions of the foot, as it might look while I walk (am I analyzing this too much? Maybe.):

…And yes, I did just reference a Justin Bieber song. So sue me.